
The Gold model that implements APC offers a practical solution to finance some publishing activities. However, this solution carries the risk of uneven distribution of the cost burden. Researchers with large grants or institutional support may be able to pay, while researchers from institutions with limited budgets face heavier barriers.
Under such conditions, financial ability can help determine access to publishing opportunities, although it should not determine the quality of research. If there is no adequate fee waiver mechanism, openness for readers can go hand in hand with inequality among authors.
However, blaming all journals that use APC is also a misguided shortcut. Journal managers need resources to run editorial processes, platform maintenance, archiving, DOI registration, and various administrative and technical work. Asking them to run all these activities without clear funding is tantamount to demanding openness without being willing to pay for the infrastructure.
The problem is not whether journals can charge fees. The problem is whether the fees are transparent, proportionate, responsibly managed, and accompanied by protections for authors who do not have the ability to pay. At the same time, universities and governments need to explain how they will support the publication infrastructure that has been part of the national knowledge ecosystem.
There are also other risks that should not be ignored. When academic career assessments are too oriented towards the number of publications or indexation status, the need to publish can meet with a publication market that offers a fast process and a certain cost. This situation needs to be watched out for because poorly designed incentives can encourage behavior that prioritizes quantity over quality. However, such risk does not mean that every paid journal is problematic or every free journal is high-grade. Integrity should be assessed based on editorial practices and relevant evidence.
The question to ask is not only, “How much does it cost to publish an article?” The more important question is, “Does this system provide a reasonable opportunity for researchers to publish quality research, regardless of the financial capabilities and strength of the institution?
#DOI
#APC
#ikafarihahhentihu
