Possible Solution: Stop Relying on One Door

If scientific openness is in the public interest, its financing should not be only a matter for each editor and writer. Indonesia needs an approach that combines several mechanisms.

First, universities and research institutions need to treat journals as academic infrastructure, not just an ancillary project. Support can be provided through transparent operational budgets, professionals, platform maintenance, digital archiving, and editorial competency development. This support should be based on clear governance and quality standards, not solely institutional proximity or administrative interests.

Second, governments and research funders can develop competitive and sustainable publication funding schemes. Such funding can be directed to journals that meet standards of transparency, quality of the review process, metadata openness, archiving, and financial accountability. Assessments should avoid over-reliance on a single index or number of publications alone.

Third, journals that implement APC need to clearly disclose fee structures, billing times, funded services, and fee waiver policies. A waiver mechanism can help authors who do not have funds. Fee waivers should also be designed so as not to affect editorial decisions about manuscript acceptance.

Fourth, Green Open Access needs to be developed through well-maintained and interoperable institutional repositories. Universities can strengthen scientific paper retention policies, provide guidance on uploadable versions of manuscripts, and ensure compliance with licenses and publisher terms. Repositories are not a substitute for all journal functions, but can be a complementary pathway to expand access.

Fifth, Indonesia needs to strengthen the Diamond Open Access ecosystem. The Indonesian Diamond Open Access portal, developed through the Indonesian Journal Volunteers initiative, is one example of efforts to build a community-based publishing ecosystem and shared infrastructure. The next step is to ensure that such initiatives are supported by long-term funding, manager training, professional editorial services, and accountable governance standards.

Sixth, the success of the policy needs to be measured using broader indicators. It is not enough for the government and universities to just count the number of indexed journals or articles published. They need to monitor the proportion of journals at no cost to authors, the affordability of APCs, the availability of fee waiver mechanisms, the sustainability of funding, the quality of the editorial process, the compliance of licenses, and the utilization of articles by the public.

The solution is not without cost and is not a guarantee of success. Public funding requires oversight, institutional support must be accompanied by accountability, and the Diamond model can still struggle when management staff or funding sources are not available. However, the combination of multiple sources of financing provides a wider scope than burdening the entire problem with authors or leaving the journal dependent on a single source of revenue.

#diamondopenaccess

#openaccess

#ikafarihahhentihu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *